DoctNik's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Archchronicler]

A good painting. The colors all seem to compliment each other and there is no great imperfection. It's also just odd enough that it really makes you wonder what an archchronicler is exactly. It's an interesting and attractive painting, something you rarely see on NG, well done.

Bertn1991 responds:

Thank so much for giving your thoughts. I'm happy you enjoyed it :D

[Bamegoy]

Neat. I like how the glowing coin lights up Bamegoy's arm and side, other than that there really isn't anything else to spectacular other than the shading (which was just a little uneven on the right arm btw.) What did you use to make this anyway? Unity or something?

Frak-Turau responds:

Thanks for the feedback! I used Magicavoxel. It's free!

[Crazy Eight]

I thought that the tentacles were over detailed when compared to the cthulhu thingy. But other than that I thought it was creepylicious yo! But seriously, you should keep in mind that an attractive painting doesn't need details, if you had left the details off the tentacles and matched the design of the carpet to the rest of the artwork than this could've been an excellant piece. Keep that in mind mate.

Bertn1991 responds:

The rug I can certainly understand, but everything else not so much. The octopus appears less detailed outside the window because he is in fog.

Thanks for the review. It's appreciate even if I don't agree :-)

[January]

I like it, the animation is fluid and really attractive. I can't wait to see the eleven others. What's the song you'll be making a music video for?

LinkTCOne responds:

Thanks!

One of my own ones, you can listen here:

www.novemberwinds.bandcamp.com

It's called evergreen from the Winter EP.

[Sketch Thing]

The beast looked intimidating and the human looked heroic and the cat was a nice touch. It probably could've been great if you finished it but as it is its a better-than-average doodle.

GhoulKitten responds:

Thanks a lot! I dunno. I MIIIIGHT finish.

[Half-empty]

Ok, so here's what I think happened: this here is the first ever woman sheriff 'round these parts, so obviously not everybody is to supportive of her. In fact, three particular ruffians decided they ought to teach her a lesson. Now, don't get 'em wrong, they'd never hurt a lil' lady, all they wanted was her badge you see.

Well, when they told her as much she didn't hessitate to teach them a lesson instead! Sadly, she was already into the bottle at this point in the day so she was only able to knock one guy on his ass before she tripped and hit the ground face first. The ruffians took her badge and now she's out to restore her honour and prove to the town that she's stronger then she deserves that badge as more than any man.

As you can tell, I really liked this artwork! I hope you make more pieces like this, I really love how it tells a story! :)

GGTFIM responds:

hah! awesome point of view ! I have her story (close to yours btw) but its in portuguese. The story is basicaly a woman sherif who captured a famous gang that makes some sort of cactus whiskey (not healty at all) and the sherif and his fellas was hanging out in a bar,when she accidentaly drink that dirty whiskey. She got really drunk and made a big mess inside the bar,ending up walking through the desert and losing her badge in this whole confusion haha.

[Heavy]

Your pieces are always funny and this one proves to be no exception. Although the guys face shows massive exertion as he struggles to move the weight, the body shows that there is little effort at all. You should've added more detail like bulging veins to really push the point.

Marklikeart responds:

Yeah probably. I'll have that in mind until next time :)

[Dragon slayer]

I like the concept, and the execution was fine, but that background doesn't fit the piece, thankfully it doesn't prove to be to much of an eye sore. Otherwise, great job, its fairly well drawn and rather funny.

Marklikeart responds:

Thanks for the feedback!